Ahp and promethee method for mining method evaluation 221 approximate the way that human mind expresses and synthesizes preferences when facing multiple contradictory decision perspectives. Project selection is a real problem of multicriteria group decision making mcgdm where each decision maker expresses hisher preferences. Finally the decision lab software implemen tation of the prometheegaia methodology is described using a numerical example. The software decision lab 2000, which supports the promethee. Promcalc was provided for all type of multi criteria problems, the promethee i, ii, v, vi and gaia visual module. It is based on extensions of the notion of criterion. Finally the decision lab software implementation of the prometheegaia methodology is described using a numerical example. Among the numerous advantages are its efficiency and easy applicability. Selection of stocks using constrained fuzzy ahp and.
Selection of the best module design for ultrafiltration. Nonfunctional parameters in this section we will introduce web service composition nonfunctional parameters in a. In this article, two new multicriteria 2tuple group decision methods called preference ranking organisation method for enrichment evaluation. The two corresponding software packages, namely decision lab for. Analytic hierarchy process ahp, promethee, delphi, multicriteria decision making, group. Finally the decision lab software implementation of the prometheegaia methodology is described using a. Promcalc and decision lab, have been developed to facilitate the promethee process. The group decision extension of promethee and gaia introduced in decision lab. After gathering and setting all required information according to promethee guidelines, the decision lab 2000 software geldermann and.
Metode promethee preference ranking of organization method for enrichment evaluation. Decision lab 16 software can be used for decision making with promethee. An overview of the promethee gdss procedure for group decision making is then given. Vahid balali 1, banafsheh zahraie 2, abbas roozbahani 3. In the promethee software promcalc and decision lab, the user is allowed to introduce arbitrary numbers for th e weights, making it easier to express the relative importance of the criteria. Decision lab, developed in collaboration with the canadian company visual decision decision lab, 2000, 1999, is the current software implementation of the promethee and gaia methods. Mining method selection by integrated ahp and promethee method. Application of prometheegaia methodology in the choice of.
The promethee method has some strength in the comparison with existing methods thanks to its simplicity and capacity to approximate the way that human mind expresses and synthesizes preferences when facing multiple contradictory decision perspectives. It is well adapted to problems where a finite number of alternative actions are to be ranked considering. Promethee network click prometheegaia promethee network to open this window. After defining the values of each criteria and assigning weights, decision lab. Using hybrid fuzzy promethee ii and fuzzy binary goal. Brans and presented for the first time in 1982 at the conference. In promethee, the overall decision can be made after calculating the weighted sum of the individual net flows.
These numbers are then divided by their sum so that the weights are normed automatically. Software decision lab 3, as a support at decision making was developed in cooperation with company visual decision, and is available to be used by individuals. Chapter 4 leader culling using ahp promethee methodology. Preference ranking organization method of enrichment evaluation promethee.
The promethee network representation of the promethee i partial ranking will feel familiar to the users of older promethee software such as promcalc or decision lab. A comparison of ahp and promethee family decision making methods for selection of building structural system. In order to decrease the necessary decisionmaking time, the methods authors developed several specialized software programs using the promethee method, namely promcalc, decision lab. Promethee ii is a widely used outranking method used in the context of multicriteria decision aid mcda. In the promethee software promcalc and decision lab, the user is allowed to introduce arbitrarynumbers for the weights, making it easier to express the relative importance of the criteria. The decision engine is implemented in the rpromkernel class. At the end of the 1990s decision lab was developed in a joint venture between the ulb. Selecting suitable semantic web service composition, using.
Decision lab 2000 software is used to get a promethee ranking. Mining method selection by integrated ahp and promethee. Dsight is the third generation prometheebased software following promcalc and decision lab. Finally the decision lab software implementation of the prometee methodology is described using the case study of begampur branch canal a numerical example. On the other hand, selecting the best equipment among many alternatives is a multicriteria decision making mcdm problem. The main aim of the proposed promethee approach is to be as easily understood as possible by the decisionmaker. Preference ranking organization method for enrichment. Promethee method implementation with multicriteria decisions 195 promethee i and promethee ii methods are developed by j. Originalityvalue the research provides a model to choose the best alternative using decision lab 2000 software for fuzzy promethee technique.
Decision lab is the current software implementation of the promethee and gaia methods. However, from the aspect of mine action, where stakeholders in the. Thus, information, as much quantitative as qualitative, coexists. Finally the dsight implementation of the promethee. Promethee merupakan metode perangkingan untuk suatu himpunan. The preference ranking organization method for enrichment of evaluations and its descriptive complement geometrical analysis for interactive aid are better known as the promethee and gaia. Promcalc was published by the authors of the method. Dsight develops innovative decision making software solutions designed to meet the real needs of consumers.
Chapter 5 promethee method promethee preference ranking organization method for enrichment evaluations. Assessing weights to the criteria is not straightforward. To apply the promethee method, dsight software was selected for ranking the various scenarios based on the results from the water and contaminant balance analysis. A sorting method based on the promethee flow scores, called flowsort, is described. The hierarchical criteria structure first available in the decision lab software. In this study, an integrated approach which employs. The given values to the criteria will be entered to the decision lab 2000 software and the same table as on table 2 is made up as shown in the figure 2. Using the promethee multicriteria decision making method to define new exploration strategies for rescue robots patrick taillandier, serge stinckwich to cite this version. Multi criteria decision making with promethee method and software 1. The promethee method is a multicriteria decision aid system that permits the building of an outranking between different alternatives. The criteria selected in this study include cost of treatment, cost per session, period of treatment, time per session, survival rate, side effects and advantages. It replaces the promcalc software that the authors had previously developed. A comparison of ahp and promethee family decision making. Fuzzy promethee analysis of leukemia treatment techniques.
Sustainability assessment of largescale composting. Software implementing the promethee and gaia mcda methods. Project selection is a real problem of multicriteria group decision making mcgdm where each decision maker expresses hisher preferences depending on the nature of the alternatives and on hisher own knowledge over them. A simplified approach to the promethee method for priority. Finally, it is necessary to assign the values of each criterion for each solution. Decision lab 2000 is a multicriteria analysis and decision support software. This article contains a short introduction to the multicriteria decision aid system promethee. It is a ranking method quite simple in conception and application compared to other methods for multicriteria analysis.
1057 650 671 432 802 1583 1021 852 1384 1149 1502 547 1266 374 823 105 1591 929 1431 255 1350 1133 772 1490 473 1085 1512 53 1504 824 782 484 772 1379 1189 766 1502 391 1388 417 1499 1130 730 721 1193 1242 1105